Ba Men Da Xuan
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Search
    • Register
    • Login

    The Path of the Heart: 70 Rules for Learning to Live Well

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Manuels de l'Ecole
    1 Posts 1 Posters 24 Views
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • Le ProfesseurL
      Le Professeur
      last edited by

      It was with the aim of guiding our minds that the handbook I would like to present to you here, The Way of the Mind: Seventy Taoist Rules for Mastering the Heart, was conceived.

      The Daxuan Taoist tradition strikes me as one of the most profound and practical responses to the concerns of the heart and mind that we are all familiar with: the anxiety that keeps us awake at night, the anger that keeps returning, the feeling that we are never doing enough, the fear of how others see us, grief, inner weariness, and that vague sense of chasing after something we can never quite grasp.

      This handbook taps into something very profound within Taoism itself. The masters of our tradition have always been wary of mere words. A Taoist handbook that merely explains would therefore be a contradiction in terms. This one has been conceived as a companion for practice: it offers a direction, an image, a gesture, and then steps aside to make way for experience.

      Most of our inner suffering does not stem from a lack of information. We know full well that there is no point in dwelling on things, that anger harms us, that we should compare ourselves less with others and enjoy the present more. We know this, and yet we carry on. The problem isn’t in our minds; it lies in habit, in the body, in those automatic reactions that have become ingrained over the years. Taoism understood this a very long time ago. It does not seek to convince us; it invites us to practise, patiently, until wisdom becomes second nature, like the cook Ding who, after years of practice, cuts up an ox effortlessly, simply following the animal’s natural joints, with a knife that remains sharp after nineteen years.

      The manual is organised into two main sections. First, there are twelve fundamental rules, which lay the foundations, followed by fifty-eight rules that apply these foundations to three major areas of life: overcoming trials, transforming oneself, and giving meaning to one’s existence. The first twelve rules are grouped around three inner attitudes which the manual refers to as disciplines: the gaze, effortless action, and maintaining the centre. The manual honestly states that this division into three disciplines is a pedagogical construct—a way of organising the material for the reader—and not a classification that one would find as such in the ancient texts. Yet each of these three attitudes is based on concepts that are well attested within the tradition, and together they form a sort of backbone that enables one to understand everything else.

      The first of these attitudes, the gaze, is perhaps the most liberating. It stems from an observation that anyone can verify: what troubles us, more often than not, is not the events themselves, but the story we tell ourselves about them. The Zhuangzi illustrates this with an image that I find extraordinarily apt. A man is crossing a river in a boat. Another boat comes and bumps into his. If he realises that this boat is empty, simply drifting with the current, he does not get angry: he pushes it away and carries on his way. But if there is someone on board, he starts shouting, then hurling insults. The impact is exactly the same. What has changed is that, in the second instance, he has perceived an intention, an offence, a lack of respect. Anger does not stem from the impact; it stems from the interpretation.

      When we start to look at our lives through this lens, something shifts. The colleague who snaps at us because they’re overwhelmed, the driver who cuts us off without seeing us, the tired loved one who forgets to thank us: how often are these actually empty boats, drifting at the mercy of their own worries, with no intention whatsoever of hurting us? The handbook does not ask us to excuse everything or to become indifferent. It simply suggests asking ourselves the question: what if the boat were empty? This single question, repeated at the right moment, dissolves a surprising amount of anger and resentment. It does not change the world, but it changes the way the world affects us.

      The same principle applies to anxiety. The handbook recounts, based on the Liezi, the story of a man from the small kingdom of Qi who could no longer sleep or eat because he feared the sky might fall on his head. Nothing had actually happened to him. He was suffering entirely from an imaginary catastrophe. The expression has remained in China to describe an unfounded fear, and I believe that each of us has our own sky threatening to fall: the fear of losing one’s job, of falling ill, of disappointing others, of falling short. Taoism does not tell us that these dangers do not exist. It invites us to distinguish between what is actually happening, here and now, and what our mind projects onto the future. Another story from the Zhuangzi puts it even more strikingly: that of a man who was afraid of his own shadow and ran to escape it, faster and faster, until he died of exhaustion, when all he needed to do was sit in the shade of a tree for his shadow to disappear. This image encapsulates a whole approach to dealing with anxiety: to stop running away, to pause, to settle down, and to discover that what was chasing us did not possess the power we had attributed to it.

      This exploration of perspective ties in with a central idea of Taoism: the relativity of viewpoints. The handbook features several stories in which very different beings view the same world in opposing ways: the frog at the bottom of its well who believes the sky is small, the summer insect to whom one cannot speak of ice, the River God who believes himself to be immense until the day he discovers the ocean. These stories are not meant to humiliate us. They gently remind us that our perspective is always partial, and that much of our suffering stems from the fact that we mistake our little well for the whole world. Broadening one’s perspective is often the first step towards soothing the heart.

      The second attitude is undoubtedly the one that most clearly distinguishes Taoism from other traditions: action without straining. This principle is often translated as ‘non-action’, which is misleading, as it is by no means a matter of sitting idly by. It is about acting in harmony with the natural course of things, rather than fighting against it. The most famous illustration of this principle is that of water. The Laozi states that nothing in the world is more supple and weaker than water, and yet nothing surpasses it in overcoming that which is hard and strong. Water does not struggle against the rock; it flows round it, seeps through it, and, over time, hollows it out. The manual also tells the story of a swimmer whom Confucius saw plunge into a waterfall so violent that not even fish could live there, and who emerged from it calmly, his hair dishevelled, singing. When asked what his secret was, he replied that he went down with the whirlpools and came back up with the eddies, that he followed the path of the water without imposing anything of his own.

      For anyone suffering from exhaustion, stress, or that feeling of having to bear everything and control everything, this principle is a real breath of fresh air. Much of our inner fatigue stems from the fact that we expend a tremendous amount of energy on resistance: resisting what has already happened, wanting others to be different, demanding that life conform to our plans. Taoism offers another way of doing things. It is not a matter of giving up, but of finding the path that does not require breaking. Chef Ding does not cut straight through the bones; he looks for the joints. When he encounters a difficult spot, he does not apply more force: he slows down, redoubles his attention, moves the knife barely at all, and the obstacle gives way of its own accord. How many of our conflicts, our stalled projects, our strained relationships would benefit from being approached in this way, by seeking out the joint rather than striking harder?

      Action without straining also involves a dimension of patience that our age has largely lost. The manual quotes the Laozi’s saying that a tree one can barely embrace grows from a tiny shoot, a nine-storey tower rises from a heap of earth, and a journey of a thousand leagues begins at our feet. It tells the story of an apprentice archer whose master made him spend years learning not to blink, then to see a louse as if it were a chariot wheel, before even allowing him to shoot an arrow. It tells the story of the old man from the Liezi who, at the age of ninety, sets out to level two mountains with his sons and grandsons, and who responds to the mockery by saying that his descendants will be endless, whilst the mountain itself does not grow. These tales free us from the obsession with immediate results. They remind us that what is built slowly is solid, that every small step counts, and that we do not need to succeed at everything today to be on the right path.

      The third attitude, maintaining one’s centre, concerns our relationship with that which is beyond our control. It is perhaps the most difficult, and it is also the one that brings the deepest peace. The idea is simple: there is a vast part of life that we do not choose. Our bodies, the times we live in, our families, illness, old age, death, the decisions of others. Faced with all this, we have a choice between two attitudes: to exhaust ourselves fighting against the inevitable, like the praying mantis in Zhuangzi’s tale who raises his legs to stop the wheel of a chariot, or to find within ourselves a stable point of support that does not depend on circumstances. Taoism calls this ‘keeping the centre’. It is a state of inner grounding, of profound calm, which enables us to remain standing when everything around us is in flux.

      ‘Keeping the centre’ finds its most moving expression in the way Taoism approaches illness and death. The manual does not shy away from these subjects, and I believe this is one of its great strengths. It tells the story of Master Lai, on his deathbed, surrounded by his weeping family, to whom his friend comes to say not to interfere with the transformation. Master Lai responds with an image I have never been able to forget: if, in the foundry, the metal were to start leaping about, crying out that it absolutely must become a famous sword, the smith would regard it as a bad omen. And if I, having once taken on human form, were to cling to it whilst refusing any other form, the great Transformation would find me just as strange. Then he falls peacefully asleep. There is also the story of Zhuangzi himself, whom his friend finds singing whilst tapping on a jar following the death of his wife. This is not a matter of indifference: Zhuangzi explains that he was initially grief-stricken, just like anyone else, but then, whilst meditating on the origin of things, he realised that life and death follow one another like the seasons, and that his wife now rests in peace in the great abode of the world.

      These stories do not ask us to deny grief. They offer another way of bearing it. For many people who are grieving, or facing illness, old age or the prospect of their own death, this view of the world as a great process of transformation – where nothing is truly lost, where the breath condenses to form a being and then disperses to return to the whole – can bring a sense of peace that few other approaches offer. It does not offer comfort through promises; it offers comfort by broadening our perspective, by placing our small lives within the vast rhythm of nature.

      Once these three attitudes have been established, the handbook puts them to the test in real life, and this is where it becomes truly valuable for the concerns of everyday life. The first major section is devoted to adversity. Here we learn to view trials not as accidents but as stages of development, in accordance with Laozi’s beautiful saying that ‘the great vessel is finished late’. It features the famous story of the old man from the frontier whose horse runs away, then returns accompanied by a stallion, which knocks his son off, breaking his leg – an incident that saves the son from the war in which almost all the young men of the village perish. At each stage, the neighbours rejoice or lament, and the old man simply replies: ‘Who knows whether this is good fortune or misfortune?’ I know of few stories as helpful for getting through hard times. It does not say that everything ends well. It says that we judge too quickly, that the meaning of an event is only revealed with time, and that wisdom lies in neither collapsing in the face of adversity nor becoming complacent in the face of success.

      This section places great emphasis on flexibility, and I believe this is one of the most valuable contributions of Taoism to our rather rigid age. The manual recounts the very ancient story of a dying old master who opens his mouth in front of his disciple and asks him if his tongue is still there, and then if his teeth are still there. The tongue is there; the teeth have fallen out. The tongue remains because it is supple; the teeth have fallen out because they are hard. The Laozi derives a universal principle from this: hardness and rigidity are companions of death; suppleness and gentleness are companions of life. A rigid mind, clinging to its certainties, breaks under the weight of the unexpected; a supple mind bends, adapts and rights itself, like bamboo after a storm. This suppleness is not weakness. It is a strength that does not tense up.

      Trials are also approached from the perspective of preparation. The handbook tells the story of the fighting cock whose trainer refuses to declare him ready as long as he remains vain, then as long as he reacts to everything, then as long as he still stares angrily at his opponent, until the day he resembles a wooden cock, so calm that the other cocks dare not face him. It tells the story of the hunchback who catches cicadas with a pole as easily as if he were picking them up off the ground, because he has trained for months to balance small balls on the end of his pole, and when the moment comes, he is focused solely on the cicadas’ wings. The lesson is clear: one does not become calm in the heat of the moment. You become so day after day, through minor annoyances, so that peace is within reach on the day you truly need it.

      The second major section, devoted to self-mastery, is perhaps the most rewarding for those battling their own demons: anger, desire, jealousy, resentment, and the need for approval. It opens with this sentence from the Laozi, which sums up its entire spirit: ‘He who knows others is wise; he who knows himself is enlightened; he who conquers others is powerful; he who conquers himself is strong.’ But what strikes me is the gentleness with which Taoism approaches this victory over the self. The handbook recounts the story of a prince who wishes to detach himself from the honours of court but is unable to do so. His adviser does not tell him to force himself. He explains that failing to conquer oneself and yet forcing oneself anyway is to wound oneself twice over. True self-mastery, from a Taoist perspective, is not an internal battle; it is a patient transformation, in which one cultivates what brings peace rather than suppressing what causes unrest.

      This approach changes everything for anyone who has already tried, without success, to correct their behaviour through willpower alone. Anger, for example, is not tackled head-on. The manual offers the image of murky water that is left to settle: if it is stirred, it remains muddy; if left undisturbed, the mud settles and the water clears of its own accord. It also tells the delightful story of a man who goes out wearing a white dress, comes home in a black one because of the rain, and wants to beat his dog, which doesn’t recognise him and barks at him. His brother stops him with a single sentence: ‘If your dog had gone out white and come back black, wouldn’t you be surprised, too?’ Often, all it takes is a moment’s step back, a change of perspective, for anger to dissipate. The same goes for suspicions and judgements: the story of the man who, having lost his axe, sees the behaviour of a thief in every gesture of his neighbour’s son, then finds his axe in his own garden and no longer sees anything suspicious in that same boy, is a merciless mirror of the way we construct grievances that exist only in our own minds.

      Desire also features prominently in this section, and I find that Taoism speaks of it with rare wisdom. It does not condemn natural desires. It warns against excessive desires—those born of comparison, vanity and the need to always have more. The textbook recounts the story of the hermit to whom the emperor offers the empire, and who calmly replies that the bird that builds its nest in the deep forest needs only a twig, and that the mole that drinks from the river takes only enough to fill its belly. It also recounts the scene in which Zhuangzi, whilst strolling through a park, sees a cicada absorbed in the shade, watched by a mantis absorbed in its prey, which is itself watched by a magpie absorbed in the mantis, and suddenly realises that he himself is aiming his crossbow at the magpie, without noticing the park ranger who is about to arrest him for poaching. Everyone, blinded by what they covet, forgets the danger that threatens them. In a world saturated with distractions, adverts and screens, this parable strikes a particular chord. Laozi had already said it: the five colours blind the eye, the five notes deafen the ear. And he offered the remedy in a single sentence of disarming simplicity: he who knows how to be content is rich.

      The way we relate to the gaze of others is another major theme, and undoubtedly one of the most painful issues today. The textbook presents the astonishing portrait of Ai Taituo, a man of frightening ugliness, without wealth, without power, without eloquence, whom yet everyone loved and wished to be in his company. His secret, the text explains, is that praise and blame, gain and loss did not enter his heart. He was dependent on nothing, and this freedom radiated from him. The handbook also quotes the description of the wise man whom the whole world might praise without his being encouraged, and criticise without his being disheartened. For those who live at the mercy of others’ reactions, compliments and criticisms, figures and approval, these texts offer a profoundly liberating perspective: our worth is not measured by the world’s shifting opinions. And there is this story, both funny and cruel, of the young man who set off for a big city to learn the elegant gait of its inhabitants, who, before he had managed to do so, had forgotten his own way of walking, and had to crawl home on all fours. Constantly comparing oneself to others, wanting to be someone else, is to risk losing who we are.

      This section concludes with pages devoted to courage, humility and forbearance. The text reminds us that one must be willing to appear foolish in order to learn, following the example of Liezi who, after years of study, returned home to cook for his wife and feed the pigs as if he were feeding people, and who finally found the Way in this rediscovered simplicity. It also reminds us that fear paralyses us, especially when we become obsessed with what is at stake, with this very astute observation: when one shoots an arrow to win a tile, one is skilful; when one shoots for a bronze buckle, one trembles; when one shoots for gold, one loses one’s head. The skill is the same. It is the importance we attach to external things that makes us clumsy on the inside.

      The third major section focuses on the meaning of life, and is undoubtedly the most illuminating. Here we discover that happiness is found within, through the portrait of that poor disciple who lives in a hut with a leaky roof and plays the lute whilst singing, and who replies to his former comrade—who has since become rich—that to possess nothing is to be poor, but that to have studied without putting it into practice is to be ill, and that he is poor, not ill. We learn to be of service to others in the manner of water, which nourishes all beings without competing with them and flows to the lowest places, following the example of the great Taoist physician Sun Simiao, who refused the honours of the court in order to treat all the sick without distinction, as if they were his closest relatives. There is also a lesson in empathy of great subtlety, in the story of the prince who wished to honour a seabird by offering it the finest music and the most exquisite dishes, and who caused it to die of fear within three days, because he had fed it as he fed himself and not as one feeds a bird. How often, with the best of intentions, do we impose on others what would please us, without asking ourselves what they really need?

      This final section finally returns to the brevity of life, not to cast a shadow over it but to make us appreciate its full value. The textbook quotes this image from the Zhuangzi, in which man passes between Heaven and Earth like a white horse before a narrow slit: no sooner has he been seen than he has vanished. It recounts the story of the ‘Dream of the Yellow Millet’, in which an ambitious young man falls asleep in an inn and, in his dream, experiences a whole lifetime of success, honours and then disgrace, before waking to find that the millet cooking on the fire is not even ready yet. It also tells of the decision of that great scholar who, at the age of thirty-six, hung his court robe on the gate of the capital and went to live in the mountains to devote himself to what truly mattered to him, and who replied to the emperor when asked what was so precious up there: ‘On the mountain peaks, there are many white clouds, which I can enjoy myself, but which I cannot offer you.’ Each of us has our own white clouds. Taoism invites us to recognise them and give them the place they deserve before the white horse has passed by.

      Why might Taoism be particularly effective in soothing the worries of the heart and mind? Having spent a long time studying these texts, I can see at least five profound reasons, which I would like to set out simply.

      The first reason is that it never separates the mind from the body. In Chinese thought, the heart is not merely an organ nor merely an emotion; it is the seat of the mind, and it is intimately linked to the breath, posture and breathing. When one’s breath is short, the mind becomes agitated; when the body is tense, the heart closes off. Conversely, when one breathes calmly into the lower abdomen, when one relaxes the shoulders and feels one’s feet rooted to the ground, the mind calms itself of its own accord. This is why so many of the exercises in the manual begin with breathing, with a return to the body, with a few minutes of stillness. Taoism does not ask us to reason our way through our emotions; it offers us a concrete, physical path to work through them. Those who practise Tai Chi, Qi Gong or meditation know this: there are anxieties that no amount of reasoning can soothe, yet which half an hour of practice can dissolve.

      The second reason is that Taoism regards inner peace as our natural state, rather than something to be achieved. A short text recited daily in Taoist monasteries, the Classic of Purity and Tranquillity, puts it very beautifully: the mind of man loves clarity, but the heart clouds it; the heart of man loves tranquillity, but desires carry it away; if one knows how to set aside one’s desires, the heart calms itself of its own accord. This perspective changes everything. We are not fundamentally restless beings who must laboriously build up a little serenity. We are naturally calm beings whom restlessness has obscured, like clear water muddied by silt. It is not a matter of adding something, but of removing what clutters us. There is immense gentleness in this idea, and immense hope: the peace we seek is already there, deep within us, like the Yellow Emperor’s black pearl, which neither intelligence, nor keen eyesight, nor eloquence had been able to find, and which was found by the one who no longer sought it with greed.

      The third reason is that Taoism fully embraces impermanence. Much of our suffering stems from our desire for things to remain as they are: to hold on to what we love, to cast out what we dislike, to freeze happiness in time, and to avoid loss. Taoism views the world as a perpetual movement, where yin transforms into yang and yang into yin, where day becomes night and night becomes day, where misfortune carries within it the seed of happiness and happiness that of misfortune. This view is not fatalistic. It is deeply reassuring, because it means that no difficulty is eternal, no failure is definitive, and no night lasts forever. The Laozi expresses this with comforting simplicity: a strong wind does not last all morning, a sudden downpour does not last all day. When we are going through a dark period, remembering that everything changes is sometimes the only thing that enables us to carry on.

      The fourth reason is that Taoism is humble. It does not claim to know everything, it does not promise to solve everything, nor does it turn its practitioner into an invulnerable hero. On the contrary, it begins by acknowledging our limitations: we do not know everything, we do not control everything; we are but a small part of an immense whole. The sage in the Zhuangzi, when asked questions, replies three times in succession: ‘How should I know?’ This humility is deeply soothing. It frees us from the exhausting demand to be right, to master everything, to live up to every expectation. It allows us to accept ourselves with our limitations, like the great sacred oak in the Zhuangzi, deemed useless by the carpenters, and which, thanks to that very uselessness, was able to become the largest and oldest of trees, offering its shade to thousands of travellers.

      The fifth reason, finally, is that Taoism is joyful. It is sometimes imagined as austere, reclusive, melancholic. It is quite the opposite. The sages of the Zhuangzi and the Liezi sing, play the lute, gently mock the powerful, and laugh at death itself. The old man Rong Qiqi, clad in a deer skin, sings in the countryside and recounts his joys to Confucius. Lin Lei, nearly a hundred years old, gleans ears of corn whilst singing in the spring. Confucius himself, besieged and starving between two kingdoms, takes up his lute again, saying that it is when the cold has set in and the snow has fallen that one comes to appreciate the vigour of the pine and the cypress. This light-heartedness is not recklessness. It is the fruit of a profound inner freedom, that of someone who no longer depends on what the world can give or take away. And it is contagious: one comes away from reading these stories with a slightly lighter heart.

      I would like to add a word on how to use this handbook, because that is where it all comes down to. It would be a shame to read it in one go, like a novel, and then put it away. It has been designed to be practised slowly. The conclusion makes this clear: one rule put into practice is better than seventy rules read. You can choose one rule a week, reread it every morning, do the suggested exercise, and observe what changes. You could also open it at random during a difficult time and see which story comes to hand. The handbook suggests keeping a small notebook – which you might call your ‘Way’ notebook – in which you jot down each evening what has happened, what you have learnt, and what you would like to do differently the following day. This practice of evening reflection has, in fact, existed in the Taoist tradition since the twelfth century, in the form of journals where practitioners recorded their good and bad deeds. It is not a matter of judging oneself harshly, but of seeing oneself clearly, with kindness, and making progress step by step.

      The exercises themselves are deliberately simple. There is nothing esoteric about them, nothing that requires any special equipment or prior knowledge. It involves breathing, observing one’s thoughts, asking oneself a question at the right moment, noting a reaction, performing a spontaneous act of kindness, slowing down when faced with a difficulty, walking in nature, and savouring a meal. Some take just a few minutes; others last a whole day. Their power lies in their repetition. As the handbook says about the hunchback and his meatballs, we fight as we have trained. Anyone who has got into the habit, when faced with minor annoyances, of asking themselves whether the boat is empty, will do the same on the day of a major offence. Anyone who has learnt to let troubled waters settle over a trifle will also know how to do so when faced with genuine anger.

      Finally, I believe this handbook can speak to a wide range of people. For practitioners, it offers the philosophical backdrop to what they experience in their bodies, and stories they can share with their students. To those interested in Taoism but unsure where to begin, it offers an accessible entry point, free from jargon, which inspires a desire to go on and read the Laozi or the Zhuangzi for themselves. To those going through a difficult time—bereavement, illness, exhaustion or a crisis—it provides simple images and actions to help them regain their footing. And to all those who have a vague sense that their lives are moving too fast, that they are wearing themselves out chasing after things that do not nourish them, it gently reminds them that there is another way of living: slower, simpler, more grounded, more in tune with the great flow of nature.

      To conclude, I return to the image of water, because it sums up better than anything else what Taoism can offer a troubled heart. Water is the gentlest thing in the world, and yet it wears away stone. It struggles against nothing, and yet nothing resists it. It takes the shape of whatever contains it without ever losing its nature. It always flows downwards, towards the places that everyone scorns, and that is why rivers and seas become the kings of all valleys. When it is agitated, it is murky; when left in peace, it clears of its own accord and faithfully reflects the sky. Learning to be like water—supple and persevering, humble and powerful, calm and vibrant—is the very path this handbook proposes. This path is not travelled by reading, but by walking, one step at a time. And as the Laozi says, a journey of a thousand li always begins beneath our feet.

      €350 – Over 160 pages.

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • Le ProfesseurL Le Professeur moved this topic from Manuels de l'Ecole

      Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

      Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

      With your input, this post could be even better 💗

      Register Login
      • First post
        Last post