Ba Men Da Xuan
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Search
    • Register
    • Login

    The Power of Nature: A Handbook on Wu Wei

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Manuels de l'Ecole
    1 Posts 1 Posters 34 Views
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • Le ProfesseurL
      Le Professeur
      last edited by

      Of all the words that Taoism has bequeathed to the world, there is one that crops up time and again, that people are keen to quote, that is printed on mugs and posters, and that almost no one really understands: wu wei, ‘non-action’. For many, it conjures up a sort of elegant idleness, a licence to do nothing, a philosophy of napping under a pine tree. For others, it denotes an ideal so lofty that it becomes unattainable, reserved for a few legendary hermits lost in the mountain mist. The book I am presenting to you today, The Power of Nature, was born out of a desire to move beyond these two misunderstandings, and to show that non-action is undoubtedly the most profound answer the Taoist tradition has ever offered to the sufferings of the heart and mind. I would like to talk to you about it without going into technical details, whilst trying to convey what moved me deeply whilst working on this subject.

      Let us begin with what wu wei is not. It is not inaction. The ancient Taoist masters never advised sitting idly by, waiting for life to take its course of its own accord. They observed something far more subtle. They looked at nature and noticed that nothing in it makes any effort to be what it is. The tree does not wonder how to grow. The water does not calculate its gradient before flowing down. The seasons do not hold meetings to decide the order in which they follow one another. And yet everything comes to pass, with a precision and beauty that our most elaborate plans never achieve. Human beings, however, have lost sight of this simple truth. They exhaust themselves trying to control their lives, to predict the future, to correct themselves, to correct others, to correct the world. They suffer from this constant struggle and do not understand why. Wu wei is the name of what we have lost: a way of acting that does not force, that follows the grain of things just as a carpenter follows the grain of the wood, and that allows an intelligence vaster than that of our own small will to flow through us.

      The handbook opens with a paradox that each of us has already encountered, even without naming it. There are moments in life when everything flows. The musician who no longer thinks about their fingers, the dancer who no longer counts their steps, the craftsman whose hand seems to know instinctively what it must do, the sportsman who ‘is in the zone’, but also the mother who spontaneously finds just the right gesture to comfort her child, the friend who says exactly the right word without having to search for it. In these moments, there is no longer any separation between the person acting and the action itself. Time expands, effort disappears, and yet the action is perfectly effective. This is what is meant by the ‘effortless mind’. But here lies the paradox: as soon as we try to recapture this state, it slips away. The more we try to relax, the more tense we become. The more one wants to be spontaneous, the more artificial one becomes. The more one seeks sleep, the more it eludes us. Anyone who has ever suffered from insomnia, anxiety or shyness knows this trap all too well. One cannot want not to want.

      This paradox has run through the entire history of Taoist thought, and the manual presents it with great clarity. Some schools of thought have held that one must first undergo prolonged discipline, adhere to rules and cultivate virtues, until discipline becomes second nature. Others, following Laozi and Zhuangzi, have believed that any imposed discipline takes us further away from our true nature, and that we must, on the contrary, unlearn. The Taoist answer is neither relentless effort nor letting things slide. It is more subtle. It consists in understanding that the effortless mind is not a state to be produced, but our true state, which we constantly obscure through our restlessness. We cannot create it, but we can stop hindering it. And this, for me, is where the true therapeutic power of Taoism begins.

      The handbook devotes an entire chapter to demonstrating that the Way of Nature is neither an ideology nor a dogma, and this is a point I find essential. Laozi did not found a religion in the sense of a system of compulsory beliefs. He did not lay down commandments. He pointed the way, and that way is always a return to nature. The handbook demonstrates with great subtlety how imposed moral codes, even the most noble ones, can become prisons. When benevolence becomes an obligation, it ceases to be benevolence and becomes a performance. When piety becomes a rule, it is stripped of its essence. The Laozi puts it bluntly: it is when the Great Way is abandoned that benevolence and justice appear. In other words, we only need moral rules because we have lost touch with our natural goodness. Those who are connected to the Way do not need to be told to be good: goodness flows from them like water from a spring.

      This chapter contains an incredible insight into what the textbook calls the ‘ghosts of control’. We believe we control our lives, but if we look closely, we discover that we control almost nothing. We do not choose our thoughts, which arise of their own accord; nor our emotions, which wash over us; nor events, which happen without asking our permission. What we call control is often nothing more than constant tension, anxious vigilance, a desperate attempt to predict the unpredictable. The Laozi compares the world to a sacred vessel that must not be touched: whoever tries to grasp it loses it; whoever tries to shape it destroys it. Letting go of control does not mean becoming passive. It means recognising that control was an illusion, and that this illusion was costing us an immense amount of energy.

      One of the most powerful images in the manual is that of the block of raw wood, the ‘pu’ of the Laozi. Before being carved, the wood contains all possible forms. Once carved into a cup, a table or a statue, it is nothing more than that. Human beings are born as raw blocks, full of possibilities; then society, education and the expectations of others gradually shape them according to models that are not their own. They become what is expected of them, and forget who they really are. Much of our depression, our deep-seated weariness and our feelings of emptiness stem from this: we are living someone else’s life. Returning to the raw block is not a regression to childhood. It is the rediscovery of our own pattern, of what tradition calls li 理 – the grain of the wood, the veins of jade, the unique inner order of every being.

      This notion of an organic pattern lies at the heart of the third chapter, devoted to harmony. The Way, says the manual, is harmony, not because it imposes a perfect order, but because every being, by following its own pattern, naturally harmonises with all others. A forest needs no architect. Each tree grows according to its nature, seeks the light in its own way, and the whole forms a balance that no gardener could conceive. The same is true of human beings. When everyone follows their own pattern, relationships harmonise of their own accord, effortlessly. Conflicts arise when we want others to follow our own pattern, or when we betray our own to follow that of another.

      The Taoist sage, says Zhuangzi, uses his heart as a mirror. The mirror retains nothing, rejects nothing, seeks nothing. It reflects whatever presents itself, and when that thing departs, it returns to emptiness. That is why it can respond to everything without ever being tarnished. We, on the other hand, cling to everything. A hurtful remark heard ten years ago still echoes in our minds. A childhood humiliation still colours our adult relationships. An old fear still dictates our choices. The mirror-heart is not an insensitive heart. On the contrary, it is perfectly sensitive, but it does not retain impressions. It feels fully, then lets it pass.

      It is in this very chapter that the handbook discusses ‘unlearning’, and I believe this is one of the most useful passages for those who suffer from anxiety or rumination. We have learnt to be wary, to anticipate the worst, to analyse every situation from every angle, and to judge ourselves constantly. These learned behaviours may have protected us at some point in our lives, but they have become automatic responses that poison us. Taoism does not suggest fighting them – which would only reinforce them – but simply observing them with calm curiosity, until they lose their hold of their own accord. The Laozi says that he who knows others is wise, but he who knows himself is enlightened. This self-knowledge is not an intellectual analysis; it is a patient, benevolent observation of what is happening within us.

      In our language, ‘virtue’ evokes a moral quality, something one earns through effort. In Taoism, Virtue is first and foremost a power, the force of the Way present and active within every being. It is this power that makes the seed grow, heals the wound, and gives the sage that tranquil radiance which one senses in his presence without being able to explain it. The Laozi contains this mind-boggling statement: ‘The highest Virtue does not seek to be virtuous; that is why it possesses Virtue; the lowest Virtue does not wish to lose its virtue; that is why it has no Virtue.’ In other words, the moment we seek to be good, we distance ourselves from true goodness. The moment we seek to be wise, we lose wisdom.

      This chapter sheds particular light on the way in which Virtue conceals itself. The text speaks of the nine orifices of the body, those gateways through which impressions from the world constantly enter: what we see, hear, taste and smell. Every impression leaves a trace, and these traces accumulate until they form habits, then deep imprints that shape our personality. We live today in a world that bombards us with impressions as never before in human history: screens, adverts, round-the-clock news, constant demands. Laozi already said that the five colours blind the eye, that the five sounds deafen the ear, that the five flavours dull the palate. What would he say today? Much of our nervous exhaustion, our restlessness and our difficulty in concentrating stems simply from this overload. The manual does not advocate fleeing the modern world, but rather becoming the guardian of one’s own gates once more, choosing what we allow in.

      This chapter also contains a very subtle reflection on spiritual pride, which the manual compares to the peacock’s wheel. It is easy, when one begins a practice, to become proud of one’s practice, to believe oneself to be more advanced than others, to display one’s serenity as one might display a designer garment. This pride is perhaps more subtle and more dangerous than ordinary pride, because it disguises itself as humility. The manual also shows, and this is a valuable distinction, that practice and non-action are not opposed to one another. They are mutually generative. Practice is like cleaning a dirty window: it does not create the light, but it allows it to pass through. And the more light passes through, the more one sees the remaining smudges, and the more natural the practice becomes, until it ceases to be an effort.

      In the fifth chapter, the handbook broadens its focus to encompass society as a whole, and it does so with a radicalism that may come as a surprise. It speaks of parasitic patterns – those structures of thought and organisation that cut us off from nature. It shows how fear, and in particular the fear of death, has become one of the great instruments of governance in human societies. But it always does so by returning to the individual, for it is within us that these patterns take root. The passage on death is truly beautiful. The textbook recalls the story of Zhuangzi who, upon the death of his wife, was found by his friend singing whilst tapping on a bowl. Outraged, the friend reproached him for his indifference. Zhuangzi replied that he had first wept, then reflected: originally, she had no life, no form, not even a breath; then, in the indistinct mixture of things, a breath appeared, then a form, then life; and now, she has transformed once more to move towards death, just as spring, summer, autumn and winter follow one another.

      The same chapter contains a reflection on conformism which I find highly relevant today. We emerge from our mother’s womb—which is nature—and are immediately taught to submit to the rules of society. We learn to measure our success in terms of money, status and recognition, and we forget to measure it in terms of peace, joy and truth. The text recounts the beautiful story of Zhuangzi fishing with a rod, to whom the King of Chu sends two ministers to offer him the rule of his kingdom. Without even turning his head, Zhuangzi asks them whether the sacred tortoise—dead for three thousand years and honourably preserved in the temple—would have preferred to be worshipped in death or to live, dragging its tail through the mud. The ministers reply that it would have preferred to live. ‘Then go away,’ says Zhuangzi, ‘I prefer to drag my tail through the mud.’ How many of us have sacrificed our living lives for dead honours? How much burnout, depression and anxiety stem from our having agreed to become sacred turtles?

      The sixth chapter, devoted to natural governance, is undoubtedly the most political in the text, yet it also speaks to each of us in our daily lives. It is based on a magnificent Chinese word, ziran 自然, which is translated as ‘natural’, but which literally means ‘of itself’. That which is natural is that which is as it is by itself, without external constraint. The Laozi places this word at the pinnacle of all things: man takes the Earth as his model, the Earth takes Heaven as its model, Heaven takes the Way as its model, and the Way takes as its model that which is ‘as it is of itself’. Even the Way has no external model. And the best ruler, says the Laozi, is the one whose people are barely aware that he exists; when the work is done, the people say: ‘It happened of its own accord.’

      This chapter has made me think a great deal about the way we govern ourselves, and the way we govern those close to us. How many parents wear their children out by trying so hard to mould them? How many couples destroy their relationships because each partner wants to change the other? How many of us tyrannise ourselves internally with demands, goals and self-reproach? The Zhuangzi contains a passage of incredible audacity, in which it places the good King Yao—a model for the entire Chinese tradition—on the same level as the tyrant Jie. One filled the people with exuberant joy; the other overwhelmed them with suffering; yet both disrupted the nature of beings—one through excitement, the other through oppression. Even good government, when it seeks to make people happy by force, goes against Virtue. I find this idea extraordinarily liberating: we do not have to make others happy, nor even to make ourselves happy through sheer effort. We must let things be, and trust in the nature of beings, including our own.

      The handbook rightly points out that this trust has nothing to do with anarchy. The anarchist is still driven by what he is fighting against; he has an agenda, an enemy, a worldview to impose. The Taoist sage has no agenda. He does not fight the established order; he lets it run its course and follows his own nature. And it is precisely this absence of an agenda that makes him transformative. The handbook uses an image from the Book of Changes that I find very beautiful: a single small piece of the jigsaw that is willing to change can transform the entire system. A single drop of perfectly clear water sends ripples throughout the ocean. We do not have to save the world. We have to become that clear drop, and the rest will take care of itself.

      The seventh chapter deals with trust, and it is perhaps the one that most directly addresses the sorrows of the heart. The handbook begins with a simple observation: our minds have been shaped to spot danger first. A single unpleasant memory weighs more heavily than ten happy ones. This instinct, useful when facing a predator, becomes a prison when it governs our entire relationship with the world. We see danger everywhere, we anticipate failure, we suspect the intentions of others. Trust is not the naïve optimism that would deny this instinct. It consists of recognising it, observing it without fighting it, and no longer letting it make decisions for us.

      Furniture, people and light come and go, but the space remains the same—never soiled, never cluttered. Our thoughts, emotions and sensations are like these visitors. They come and go. That which welcomes them neither comes nor goes. When we discover this—not as an idea but as an experience—something deep within us relaxes. Nothing that happens can threaten the space in which it happens. Fear, anger and sadness become visitors whom we can welcome fully, then let go. The manual, however, warns against a common mistake: trying to create a state of emptiness, or to silence one’s thoughts by force. What one ends up with is a rigid void, which is merely one more thought: the thought of not thinking. The space of consciousness is not a blank screen; it is alive, open and sensitive.

      The story that the manual places at the heart of this chapter is that of the swimmer from Lüliang, and I believe it is one of the most beautiful in the Zhuangzi. Confucius contemplates a vast waterfall, so violent that no fish or tortoise can swim in it. He sees a man throw himself into it and, believing him to be in despair, sends his disciples to rescue him. But the man emerges further downstream, his hair dishevelled, and strolls along singing. Confucius asks him if he has a method. The man replies that he has none: he enters with the whirlpool and emerges with the eddy; he follows the course of the water and brings nothing of his own to it. He adds that he does not know why he does this, and yet he does it. This, it seems to me, is the perfect image of trust. The swimmer does not struggle against the waterfall; he would be crushed. Nor does he let himself drift like a drowning man. He goes with the flow of the water. Most of us go through life like poor swimmers in a torrent: we struggle, we exhaust ourselves, we swallow the very water we are fighting against. The current of life is not our enemy.

      The eighth chapter is the one that will resonate most with practitioners of internal martial arts and Chinese medicine, but I believe it concerns everyone. It is devoted to the cultivation of yin. The manual begins with an observation that any practitioner of Chinese medicine will recognise: our entire civilisation resembles an organism deficient in yin. In the body, a deficiency of yin manifests as internal heat, restlessness, insomnia and an inability to settle down. Yang, deprived of its anchor, runs wild like a fire without water. Our world exhibits precisely these symptoms. Time is money; we must produce, speed things up, be available at all hours; rest is viewed with suspicion, slowness is a flaw, silence is a void to be filled. And to keep up with this pace, we turn to stimulants, which whip up an already exhausted yang and further deplete the yin. The handbook honestly states that this is an analogy drawn from Chinese medicine, not a medical diagnosis, but the analogy is strikingly accurate.

      Many people imagine that balance means fifty-fifty. The handbook uses the example of tea: a few leaves are enough for a large quantity of water, and if one were to use as many leaves as there is water, the drink would be undrinkable. Balance is not equality; it is the right proportion. A balanced life may require a great deal of calm, receptiveness and slowness, and a little action and decisiveness at the right moment. The manual also reminds us that the first thing one learns in martial arts is not how to strike, but how to fall. The beginner, stiff with fear, injures themselves with every fall; the one who learns to relax can fall a hundred times without harm. Life causes us to fall constantly, and the one who knows how to fall gets back up.

      It is in this chapter that we find the ‘fasting of the heart’, one of the most profound teachings of the Zhuangzi. The disciple Yan Hui wishes to go and set a cruel young prince straight. Confucius shows him that all his strategies will only provoke the prince, because they still stem from his own agenda, and advises him to fast. Yan Hui replies that he is poor and already eats neither meat nor drinks wine. Confucius explains that he is not speaking of the fast of sacrifices, but of the fast of the heart: do not listen with the ear, listen with the heart; do not listen with the heart, listen with the breath; the breath is empty and welcomes all beings, and only the Way gathers within the void. And Yan Hui, having practised this, utters this deeply moving phrase: ‘Before, I was truly Hui; now, there has never been a Hui.’ It is only on this condition—having cast off his own self—that he can face the dangerous prince. Fasting of the heart is not an escape from the world; it is preparation for the most delicate of actions.

      The ninth chapter tackles a more mysterious subject: that of coincidences. Anyone who begins to live with less resistance notices that events seem to fall into place of their own accord. You think of someone, and they ring. A chance encounter changes the course of a life. The manual explains that ancient Chinese thought recognises, alongside mechanical causality, another principle which it calls resonance: beings of the same nature call out to one another and respond, just as two strings tuned to the same note vibrate together. The Book of Changes states that similar sounds respond to one another, that similar breaths seek each other out, that water flows towards moisture and that fire moves towards dryness. A heart attuned to the Way resonates with events that correspond to its nature. The manual is careful not to turn this into superstition: it does not say that every coincidence is a message; rather, it invites us to perceive the profound harmony between our inner state and the flow of our lives.

      This chapter also contains a reflection on destiny which I find to be deeply wise. The Zhuangzi states that whoever realises there are things beyond one’s control, and accepts them peacefully as destiny, has reached the pinnacle of Virtue. This acceptance is not resignation. Resignation is bitter; it continues to struggle internally whilst yielding externally. Taoist acceptance is peaceful. It no longer struggles, and this peace releases immense energy, previously wasted on resistance. The manual adds an observation that many people in distress will recognise: what we refuse to look at within ourselves comes back to us from the outside, in the form of events. Those who deny their anger constantly encounter angry people; those who refuse their fear find themselves in frightening situations. Until we have embraced these parts of ourselves, life reflects them back to us, like a patient mirror.

      The tenth chapter bears a provocative title: ‘Nothing is more useless than wu wei.’ It addresses the objection that everyone eventually raises: ‘What is the point of it all?’ And it answers with a reversal. The Laozi says that thirty spokes converge at a hub, and that it is the emptiness of the hub that allows the wheel to turn; that we shape clay to make a vase, and that it is the hollow inside that allows the vase to hold anything; that we cut out doors and windows to make a house, and that it is their emptiness that allows us to live there. We see the spokes, the clay, the walls, but never the emptiness; and yet it is the emptiness that serves its purpose. The Zhuangzi also tells the story of a huge tree, so twisted, so bitter, so useless that no carpenter would have it, and which, for that very reason, was able to live for centuries and shelter thousands of travellers in its shade. Straight trees are felled whilst young; the well with fresh water runs dry first.

      I find this chapter invaluable for all those who wear themselves out trying to be useful, indispensable, high-achieving. How many people, particularly amongst the most generous, wear themselves out through their desire to serve, to help, to succeed? Taoism does not tell them to become selfish. It tells them to stop allowing themselves to be reduced to a mere instrument. The manual concludes this chapter on water, the supreme symbol of wu wei. The supreme good is like water, says the Laozi: it benefits all beings without competing, it dwells in places that all others spurn, and that is why it is close to the Way. Water always flows downwards. Everyone wants to rise; no one disputes its descent. In this humility lies a secret to peace and longevity: he who does not compete does not exhaust his breath in futile struggles; he who remains lowly cannot fall.

      The final major chapter brings all this back to everyday life, and it is the one I would recommend to those who fear that Taoism is an escape. The text is very clear: wu wei does not require one to go and live in a cave. Zhuangzi himself did not do so; he married, debated with his friends, and lived amongst people. His ideal is the free-spirited stroll, that way of moving through life without a fixed destination, savouring every step, working, loving, acting – yet with a heart that is not attached to any outcome. The handbook speaks of relationships that grow organically rather than being constructed, of personal love that ceases to be possessive when it is rooted in a broader love, and of the violence we consume as entertainment, which desensitises our hearts.

      This is the trap of using spirituality to avoid facing one’s own wounds. Instead of acknowledging one’s anger, one claims to be detached. Instead of recognising one’s fear, one speaks of trust in the Way. Instead of healing one’s relational wounds, one proclaims oneself to be beyond attachments. The handbook illustrates with great clarity how this trap manifests itself: a superficial calm that masks constant tension, a sense of superiority over others, and a forced optimism that denies real suffering. True wu wei is not an escape from our shadow side. It is an acceptance so complete that it also encompasses our darker aspects. The manual reminds us that anger, when experienced mindfully, is a healthy energy; that addictions have something to teach us about our own shortcomings; and that walking away from a destructive relationship can be the most natural thing to do, just as water flows round a rock rather than crashing against it. It also honestly recommends, in the case of deep-seated wounds, that we should not hesitate to seek professional help alongside our practice.

      The manual concludes this chapter with the parable of Hundun, on which the inner chapters of the Zhuangzi end. Two rulers, Shu and Hu, whose names both mean ‘swift, sudden’, are received kindly by Hundun, the ruler of the Centre, the primordial Chaos. To thank him, they decide to pierce the seven orifices that all men possess but which he lacks. Every day they pierce one, and on the seventh day, Hundun dies. I know of no more apt image of what we do to nature, to children, to others, and to ourselves, even with the best of intentions. We want to improve, correct, and make things ‘normal’, and in doing so we kill what was alive. Haste – which is the very name of these two rulers – is the enemy of naturalness.

      Each section ends with a short box summarising the key points, so that one can quickly revisit them. Most chapters offer very simple exercises, which do not claim to produce wu wei – which would be a contradiction – but rather to clear the ground, just as one removes stones from a field before the rain does its work. For example, there is an exercise that involves leaving someone close to you to their own devices for a week, without offering unsolicited advice or correction, observing them as one might observe a growing tree. Another invites you to choose the humble position each day, to let others speak first, to carry out a thankless task without drawing attention to it, and to observe what this awakens within you. Yet another suggests an evening prayer without any requests, consisting solely of gratitude, including for a difficult moment from the day. All quotations from the classics are provided alongside the Chinese text, for those who wish to verify or explore them further, and a glossary at the end of the volume makes the Chinese terms accessible to all. Above all, the handbook always clearly distinguishes between what belongs to the attested tradition and what stems from modern interpretation or parallels, which I believe is essential for honest work.

      All our usual methods for feeling better rely on effort: doing more, controlling things better, correcting ourselves further. Taoism tells us that it is precisely this effort that causes us suffering, and that healing begins when we stop struggling against what is. Not through resignation, but through trust. Not through passivity, but through a focus so subtle that it follows the natural flow of things rather than forcing it. We do not need to become natural; we already are. We simply need to stop getting in the way.

      The handbook concludes with a quote from an ancient Chinese thinker, regarding Heaven which breathes forth without intending to bring beings into being, and beings come into being of their own accord: this is what non-action is. I love this image of a power that gives without intention, that brings life without will, that accomplishes everything without forcing anything. It is within us too, in our breath, in the silent wisdom of our bodies, in that part of us that has never ceased to know how to live. No book can give it to us, and this handbook humbly acknowledges this. It can only show us where to look. The rest belongs to life itself, to our own journey, to our encounters and our trials.

      After all, if the Way can be approached anywhere, it is undoubtedly in these unscripted exchanges, where no one seeks to convince the other, and where everyone simply lets the water flow.

      €350 – Over 140 pages.

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • Le ProfesseurL Le Professeur moved this topic from Manuels de l'Ecole

      Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

      Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

      With your input, this post could be even better 💗

      Register Login
      • First post
        Last post